The Jamestown Comet

Posts Tagged ‘Xenia Area Community Theater’

Xenia community theater presents a Christmas comedy with frightful twist

In Children and Family, Local News, Uncategorized on November 18, 2026 at 12:00 pm
Xenia Area Community Theatre (X*ACT) “Santaphobia” cast photo. Photo by Gery Deer

By Gery Deer

XENIA, Ohio – Most families look forward to a visit from Santa Claus at Christmas. The Gruber family would rather run screaming in the opposite direction. And if there’s a fortune at stake, they might just make sure everyone else runs first as Xenia Area Community Theater (X*ACT) presents, “Santaphobia,” December 4th through the 13th.

Written by Kamron Klitgaard and directed by Melissa Baughn, the family-friendly production promises an evening of outrageous antics, unusual Christmas traditions and a little holiday wisdom tucked beneath the laughter. The show combines family feuds, a mysterious inheritance and a fear of Santa Claus in a madcap comedy about finding your way back to family.

The story centers on Alice Gruber, a wealthy widow whose grown children have become estranged from one another following years of family disagreements and unresolved troubles. Her late husband invested his hard-earned money in insurance policies, leaving behind a substantial fortune and a family that can barely stand to be in the same room.

Alice has a plan to bring them together for one last traditional Gruber family Christmas. There’s just one rather peculiar complication: Her children have a deeply rooted fear of Santa Claus. And in the Gruber household, Santa isn’t merely unwelcome. He’s practically the family equivalent of a forbidden name.

Alice offers her children and their families a share of the inheritance if they will spend Christmas Eve together at the family mansion. But rather than embrace the opportunity for reconciliation, the siblings begin plotting to frighten one another away and claim the fortune for themselves.

The result is a series of increasingly ridiculous schemes, disguises and elaborate attempts to terrorize the competition, all built around the one thing everyone fears most.

According to the production team, the comedy features a decidedly Scooby-Doo-style approach to frightening the family members, with plenty of surprises along the way.

But while the antics are designed to keep audiences laughing, Baughn says the story’s underlying message is what attracted her to the production.

“I picked this play for its funny story line and because it centers on a family who is messy and complicated in many ways like our own,” Baughn said. “We so often let simple disagreements keep us from our loved ones, especially at Christmas.”

That familiar family dynamic gives the comedy an unexpected emotional center. Beneath the exaggerated characters and absurd situations is a recognizable story about people who have allowed old arguments, misunderstandings and stubbornness to become more important than their relationships.

“This story uses comedy to show that small things can become much larger than they should be allowed,” Baughn said.

For Baughn, the production also marks a personal milestone: her first time directing a show. Over the past four years, she has served as assistant director on several melodramas alongside longtime X*ACT volunteer Melodee Bass, including Trouble Bubbles at the Hot Springs and Dirty Deeds at the Depot. This time, the two have exchanged roles, with Baughn taking the director’s chair and Bass serving as assistant director.

The collaboration has given Baughn an opportunity to build on her theatrical experience while guiding a large ensemble through a comedy that depends on timing, exaggerated personalities and the escalating chaos of a family determined to outwit itself.

Bass said watching the performers develop their characters has been one of the most enjoyable aspects of bringing the show to the stage. She has particularly enjoyed “watching the talented actors develop the quirky traits that bring their characters to life and make them memorable.”

The production brings together performers of different ages, including children, teenagers and adults, creating a multigenerational cast that reflects the family at the center of the story. “The children, teens and adults have been a joy to work with, and the families have been beyond supportive,” Bass said.

Ann Fields leads the cast as Alice Gruber, with Michael Traina portraying Winston. Matthew Benefiel plays Charles Gruber, Candice Jasinski appears as Maggi, Viv Kemp portrays Sandra and Lexi Bailey takes the role of Lorena.

The cast also includes Deborah Benefiel as Aurora, Travis Tyler Shane as George Gruber, Melanie Brown as Nellie, Andy Jasinski as Ricky, Ransom Curby as Mickey, Miriam Gehrich as Cindy and Mollie Curby as Mindy. Rounding out the ensemble are Anna June as Ma Bee, Madelyn Phillips as Nancy Gruber and Malachi Benefiel as Paul.

While the audience will encounter plenty of peculiar characters and comic surprises, the production team is keeping some of the Gruber family’s secrets under wraps, including the origins of their unusual Christmas traditions and the events that drove the siblings apart. Those revelations are part of the fun, and perhaps part of the lesson.

For all its exaggerated comedy, Santaphobia raises a familiar holiday question: How many families allow disagreements from years past to overshadow the reasons they should be together in the first place?

Baughn sees the Christmas season as an opportunity to remember the importance of forgiveness, particularly through the Christian message at the heart of the holiday.

Bass, meanwhile, hopes audiences will simply give themselves permission to escape the seasonal rush and enjoy an evening of laughter. “This is an amazingly sidesplitting show that everyone needs to take time out from the holiday rush to enjoy!” she said.

For families looking for something different from the usual Christmas entertainment, Santaphobia offers a combination of slapstick humor, holiday mystery and a reminder that even the most complicated families might find their way back to one another. Of course, in the Gruber household, getting there may require surviving Christmas Eve first.

Santaphobia will be presented Dec. 4-6 and Dec. 11-13 at Xenia Area Community Theater and Arts Center, 45 E. Second St., Xenia. Friday and Saturday performances begin at 7 p.m., with Sunday matinees at 3 p.m. Photos with Santa are also planned.

General admission tickets are $20, with discounted $17 admission for students, seniors and military personnel. Tickets are available through the theater’s website or at the door, subject to availability. For more information or to purchase tickets, visit www.xeniaact1.org or email xeniaarea@gmail.com.